QKS Logo
QKS Library Icon

QKS Library

NewsroomSPARK Plus™Sign In
QKS Logo

QKS Review: AI Meets SecOps: The Top Players Every RSA Attendee Should Know

FolderIcon

30.04.2025

QKS Review

QKS Review: AI Meets SecOps: The Top Players Every RSA Attendee Should Know

Author:

Venkatesh Kopparthi

backgroundImage
FolderIcon

Executive Summary:

As the Security Orchestration, Automation, and Response (SOAR) market faces rising pressure from alert fatigue, analyst shortages, and increasingly sophisticated threats, organizations are moving beyond traditional manual or semi-automated incident response tools.


This review blog by QKS Group assesses whether AI-driven SOAR vendors are truly innovating to meet these demands - or merely making incremental updates.

What Modern SOAR Platforms Should Deliver:
Today’s platforms must offer more than core workflow automation. Critical next-gen capabilities include:
• Agentic AI and intelligent assistants for context-aware decision support
• Private LLMs and generative AI for case summarization and automated playbook creation
• Adaptive machine learning for real-time threat detection and response optimization

Key Findings:
• Leading vendors (Swimlane, Palo Alto Networks, Cisco (Splunk)) stand out with enterprise-grade AI capabilities, private assistants, and advanced automation that support high-throughput, real-time SecOps.
• Capable vendors (D3 Security, Tines) show promising applications of AI, though many are still evolving toward deeper integration and customization.
• Lagging vendors (Fortinet, Torq, Anomali) continue to rely on legacy automation models or under-leverage their core strengths, limiting their ability to deliver on AI’s full potential.

AI is transforming SOAR by enabling SOC team with intelligent recommendations, automated workflows, and rapid incident response at scale, by leveraging advanced AI capabilities such as generative AI, agentic AI, and machine learning. SOAR platforms reduce SOC analyst workload, enhance response accuracy, and accelerate incident mitigation, shifting security operations from manual, reactive processes to proactive, AI-driven automation.  Explore how leading vendors are transforming security operations through AI in our latest QKS AI Maturity Matrix: Empowering SecOps with Intelligent Recommendations. This analysis reveals which platforms go beyond automation to deliver real-time, context-aware decision support.

The modern security operations center (SOC) confronts an overwhelming pile of alerts per day, with a network of security tools, and a persistent shortage of skilled analysts. This challenging environment makes it increasingly difficult for security teams to effectively manage and respond to cyber threats that are evolving at an alarming rate. Security Orchestration, Automation, and Response (SOAR) platforms emerged as a solution, promising to automate repetitive incident response tasks and streamline incident response workflows. However, as cyber threats grow more sophisticated, the need for advanced capabilities beyond basic automation has become evident. This has catalyzed the integration of Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Machine Learning (ML) into SOAR solutions, offering the potential for more intelligent and streamlined security operations. This analysis examines the AI capabilities provided by various SOAR vendors, offering a critical perspective on their current offerings, effectiveness, and future potential.

The Leaders' Circle: Embracing AI for SecOps Transformation

Swimlane: Leading with Agentic AI in SecOps Automation

Swimlane has positioned itself at the lead of this evolution, with a modern approach to SOAR that heavily emphasizes AI-enhanced security automation. The company envisions a future dominated by AI hyperautomation that can seamlessly integrate with any security tool and automate at enterprise scale. The concept of "Agentic AI" suggests a significant shift toward more autonomous and intelligent security operations, moving beyond simple rule-based automations to truly adaptive systems. Their platform, Swimlane Turbine, offers a comprehensive suite of AI-powered features, including Swimlane LLM, a private agentic AI companion, and AI-driven tools for case summarization, reporting, context-aware recommended actions, and even playbook building.

Hero AI, a fundamental component of Swimlane Turbine, is a private and secure AI automation innovation designed to augment security operations rather than replace human analysts. It functions as an intelligent assistant for SecOps teams, offering capabilities like AI-driven case summarization to rapidly understand complex incidents, context-aware recommended actions to guide analysts through response procedures, and AI-augmented reporting to generate stakeholder-ready reports in multiple languages. The platform extends its AI capabilities with features such as AI playbook actions, enabling the use of playbook data in AI prompts without complex scripting, and schema inference, which simplifies the mapping of dynamic data across various use cases. Swimlane claims, stating that its platform executes 25 million daily actions per customer and is 17 times faster than competitors. It suggests a solution built for high-throughput environments capable of handling the immense data volumes characteristic of modern SOCs.

With such a strong emphasis on “Agentic AI,” one must question whether Swimlane can ensure transparency and explainability in its AI’s decision-making processes especially when providing context-driven case summaries and recommended actions during critical incident responses. Swimlane recognizes this concern and has prioritized enhanced AI audit capabilities on its roadmap. These features will surface decision rationale directly within the platform, so analysts can trace why Hero AI suggested each action. Likewise, while automation at this scale promises significant efficiency gains, it also raises the possibility of new vulnerabilities. Swimlane acknowledges that any new process can introduce risk and therefore conducts routine code-vulnerability scans and maintains comprehensive logs of Hero AI’s actions to ensure full audit trails and continuous process reviews.

Palo Alto Networks (Cortex XSOAR): Infusing Machine Learning for Intelligent Security Operations

Palo Alto Networks’ Cortex xsoar also stands as a leader in the SOAR market, heavily leveraging AI and machine learning to enhance security operations. The platform aims to analyze vast amounts of security data, automate repetitive tasks, and streamline incident response processes, ultimately improving an organization's overall security posture and operational efficiency. Cortex XSOAR leverages machine learning to improve analyst productivity by suggesting incident owners and providing expert recommendations based on historical data. It also accelerates playbook development by offering intelligent recommendations and promotes standardized responses by recommending common security commands. These ML features are designed to assist analysts throughout the entire incident lifecycle, from initial alert triage to final resolution, and even in the creation and optimization of automation workflows.

A notable AI capability within Cortex XSOAR is its phishing analysis playbook, which utilizes machine learning-based checks on phishing emails and URLs to accurately predict whether they are malicious or not. This demonstrates a practical application of ML to address a critical security threat, automating the detection of phishing attempts and reducing the workload on security analysts. Furthermore, Palo Alto Networks has introduced "Cortex Copilot," an AI-powered assistant integrated within their Cortex XSIAM platform. This copilot aims to simplify how security analysts gather information and execute security actions by using natural language, making the platform more user-friendly and intuitive. This represents a strategic move towards leveraging generative AI to directly assist analysts in their daily investigative tasks.

While Cortex XSOAR offers various ML capabilities, critical questions remain about how these models are continuously updated and adapted to the evolving threat landscape. Security threats change rapidly, and ML models can quickly become outdated if not regularly retrained with fresh data. Additionally, the level of customization provided to organizations to fine-tune these models to their specific environments and threat profiles remains unclear. Different industries face different threat actors with varying tactics, techniques, and procedures, making the ability to customize ML models crucial for effective security operations. Without sufficient transparency into the training data and algorithms used, organizations may struggle to trust and validate the recommendations provided by Cortex XSOAR's ML features.

Cisco (Splunk SOAR): Leveraging AI to Enhance Detection and Response

Cisco, through its Splunk SOAR platform, also aims to bring order to the often chaotic environments of security operations centers by providing extensive integration capabilities and robust automation. Splunk SOAR's primary goal is to unify security operations and significantly improve response times through its wide array of integrations and powerful automation features. While automation is a core focus, AI, particularly machine learning, plays an increasingly important role in enhancing the platform's capabilities, especially in streamlining response processes and effectively prioritizing security alerts. Splunk leverages its data-centric approach, with machine learning algorithms, to analyze patterns and help security teams focus on the most critical threats.

Like its competitors, Splunk has introduced an "AI Assistant for Security," in private preview designed to expedite the investigations and daily workflows of security analysts by using generative AI. This assistant provides analysts with workflow guidance and can summarize incident data, aiming to simplify the investigative process and enhance overall efficiency. A significant development for Splunk SOAR users is the integration of Cisco Talos threat intelligence across Splunk's security product suite, including Splunk SOAR. This integration promises to enrich Splunk SOAR with real-time, actionable threat intelligence, enabling security teams to make more informed decisions and respond to both known and emerging threats with improved speed and accuracy.

Now that Splunk is part of Cisco, questions arise about how they will ensure a cohesive and integrated AI strategy across both organizations' security portfolios. The acquisition creates potential for synergy but also confusion and overlapping capabilities that could complicate rather than streamline security operations. Furthermore, while the integration of Cisco Talos threat intelligence sounds promising, the practical implementation and the specific benefits this unified approach will bring to Splunk SOAR users in terms of advanced AI-powered capabilities remain to be seen. Will this integration truly enhance threat detection and response through AI-powered analysis, or will it simply add another layer of data without meaningful intelligence? Additionally, as with other AI-powered security solutions, concerns about explainability, false positives, and the potential for automation bias remain questionable.

The AI Adoption Middle Ground: Strategic Restraint or Missed Opportunity?

D3 Security: Taking a Step into the AI Arena

D3 Security appears to be taking a more measured approach to AI integration, offering Morpheus AI for Threat Investigation, Triage, and Remediation. While they are leveraging AI to automate core security operations tasks through their playbooks, their level of sophistication seems limited compared to the leaders in this space. The AI integration appears to focus primarily on automating triage and response actions without the more advanced agentic AI or extensive ML-driven features seen in platforms like Swimlane and Cortex XSOAR saying Morpheus AI is more of a unified intelligence.

This measured approach to AI adoption raises important questions about D3 Security's long-term competitive position in an increasingly AI-driven market. While caution might ensure more reliable and trustworthy implementations, it could potentially lead to a widening capability gap compared to more aggressive competitors. However, their focus on core functionality rather than AI hype could potentially appeal to organizations more concerned with practical results than cutting-edge features.

Tines: Exploring the Potential of AI in Streamlining Workflows

Tines currently occupies a similar stand with its competition when it comes to AI in its SOAR platform. The solution shows that it is exploring AI applications, Tines’ Automatic Mode can transform complex data through generated code prompted by simple instructions, handling tasks such as data interpretation, formatting, and summarization. Similarly, its AI action enables users to call a language model directly within workflows without training, logging, or storing the data. Tines’ newest product Workbench provides a natural language interface where users can take action and access proprietary data in real-time, privately and securely. Overall, Tines appears to leverage AI primarily to streamline existing automation workflows and handle limited use cases, rather than integrating deep, advanced AI capabilities across the platform.

Currently, the company offers a tool known as “Tinkerer,” which can generate an initial workflow from a few sentences of plain English. However, this tool remains a standalone demo rather than a fully integrated feature. Tines’ Workbench also enables teams to perform AI-driven case triage and enrichment. Using tools and stories, Workbench can perform a preliminary pass over alert data correlating, enriching, and suggest next steps before handing off decisions that require irreversible actions to a human analyst. This reflects a cautious yet deliberate approach, where human oversight remains in loop given the current limitations of fully autonomous AI agents.

Overall, Tines’ approach to incorporating AI into its SOAR offering is measured. While it leverages AI to streamline data transformation and workflow automation, its current focus is on enhancing existing processes rather than making AI the central pillar of its platform. In a competitive market where advanced AI capabilities are increasingly seen as a differentiator, organizations should carefully evaluate Tines’ roadmap. The key question for potential customers is whether this measured strategy represents thoughtful restraint ensuring safety and compliance or if it might eventually limit their ability to achieve truly intelligent, adaptive security operations as threat landscapes evolve.

Left Behind: Why Some SOAR Vendors Are Failing to Deliver on AI’s Promise

Fortinet: AI Capabilities Behind Expectations

Fortinet’s FortiSOAR claims to offer "built-in threat intelligence" and a recommendation engine for "AI-driven security operations" and "playbook creation." However, these features appear less effective when compared to offerings from leading vendors. The "AI-driven" aspects through Fortinet Advisor leverages natural language processing and generative AI to deliver context-aware incident analysis, actionable guidance, and automated playbook creation. The critical question regarding FortiSOAR's AI capabilities is whether their AI can go beyond recommendations and truly demonstrate intelligent learning and adaptation in real-world threat scenarios. Fortinet's position as a comprehensive security vendor may allow them to leverage integration advantages, but without sophisticated AI capabilities, FortiSOAR risks falling behind as the market continues to evolve toward more intelligent security automation solutions.

Torq: Speed-Focused: Hyper Automation

Torq markets its platform as "Hyperautomation" to streamline security operations by automating common and complex security use cases claiming to be 10 times faster than legacy SOAR solutions. The vendor promotes an enterprise-grade security architecture that scales elastically to handle a cloud-native data pipeline, integrate with any solution in the modern SOC, and leverage agentic AI and AI-Generated Workflows. The question remains whether their platform can truly offer the intelligent functionalities that modern SOCs increasingly require. In a market where AI is increasingly becoming a core component of effective SOAR solutions, the term “Hyperautomation" suggests speed and scale but doesn't necessarily imply intelligence or adaptability. Similarly, references to "agentic AI" echo industry buzzwords without clearly demonstrating unique capabilities that provide tangible advantages over competitors. Organizations considering Torq's solution should look beyond to understand the practical benefits and limitations of their AI implementation, particularly in complex security scenarios that require adaptive intelligence rather than just accelerated execution of predefined workflows.

Anomali: AI Recommendations Still Catching Up

Anomali, known for its threat intelligence platform, appears to be trailing particularly in the context of threat intelligence integration and automated response. Given Anomali's established expertise in threat intelligence, one would expect their SOAR platform to deeply leverage AI to analyze and act upon threat data. However, Anomali's AI capabilities within their SOAR solution, through Anomali Copilot to "Automate Data-Driven Decisions," "AI-Powered workflow," "Automate manual and repetitive tasks with AI-Powered security orchestration," and NLP support, suggest that their AI contributions are not significantly impactful in enhancing threat intelligence integration and automated response. This raises concerns about whether Anomali is truly capitalizing on its core threat intelligence by effectively integrating advanced AI into its SOAR platform to provide a distinct advantage over competitors.

Considering Anomali's expertise in threat intelligence, the questions about how their SOAR platform truly leverages AI to intelligently analyze, correlate, and act upon threat intelligence data in a way that provides a significant advantage over competitors. The disconnect between Anomali's core competency in threat intelligence and their AI capabilities in their SOAR offering represents a missed opportunity to deliver uniquely valuable capabilities to security teams.

Future Outlook: The Trajectory of AI in SOAR

Looking ahead, AI is set to play an increasingly pivotal role in the evolution of SOAR, driving a shift towards more autonomous and intelligent security operations. The industry trend clearly indicates a future where AI will be deeply woven into the fabric of SOAR platforms, enabling more proactive threat detection, dramatically faster incident response times, and a reduced reliance on manual intervention from security analysts. This transition from reactive to proactive security postures represents a fundamental transformation in how organizations approach cybersecurity challenges.

Author: Venkatesh Kopparthi, Analyst at QKS Group

Vendors: