QKS Logo
QKS Library Icon

QKS Library

NewsroomSPARK Plus™Sign In
QKS Logo

12.01.2026

QKS Review

Beyond the Blame Game: Why Vendors alone are not to blame for users not getting 100% value from IT solutions

Author:

Nikhilesh Naik

backgroundImage
FolderIcon

Executive Summary:

As enterprises invest heavily in modern IT platforms to drive automation, cloud modernization, AI adoption, and operational efficiency, expectations of rapid and measurable value realization have intensified. However, despite mature platforms and strong vendor ecosystems, many organizations continue to report value shortfalls, delayed outcomes, and limited business impact. This has led to a recurring pattern where vendors are positioned as the primary source of failure when promised transformation does not materialize.

What Enterprises Expect from Modern IT Platforms

Today’s IT platforms are increasingly viewed not as tools, but as transformation accelerators. Enterprises expect them to deliver rapid time-to-value with minimal disruption, integrate seamlessly across legacy and modern environments, and embed governance, compliance, and automation directly into everyday workflows. Most importantly, platforms are expected to produce predictable ROI and measurable business outcomes soon after deployment, without requiring fundamental changes to existing operating models.

What Users Commonly Blame Vendors For

When these expectations are not met, responsibility is most often assigned to vendors. Users cite extended time-to-value compared to pre-sales projections, difficulties integrating platforms into complex legacy estates, and a perceived gap between technical improvements and business-level outcomes. Vendors are also blamed when embedded governance and compliance capabilities fail to replace manual controls, or when platforms require substantial consulting and partner involvement to operate effectively at scale. In many cases, these issues are interpreted as product shortcomings rather than environmental or organizational constraints.

How These Perceptions Connect to the Broader Value Gap

The issues users attribute to vendors closely mirror the structural themes explored in this blog. Modern platforms are designed to operate in environments with clear ownership, standardized processes, coherent architectures, and change-ready cultures. When deployed into fragmented operating models, legacy-heavy landscapes, and governance structures resistant to automation, platforms inevitably fall short of expectations. The resulting value gap is therefore less a failure of technology and more a mismatch between platform capability and organizational readiness, a disconnect that fuels recurring disappointment and reinforces the cycle of vendor blame highlighted throughout this analysis.

This article by QKS Group examines whether these perceptions are rooted in genuine vendor shortcomings or whether they reflect deeper organizational and execution gaps within user environments.

In Boardrooms from Silicon Valley to Tokyo, a familiar ritual goes around where the deck presented by a vendor promises “instant scalability”, “zero-touch deployment”, “continuous deployment”, “automated compliance”, everything that today’s business craves, and the deal gets fnalized when enterprise executive clicks “Accept” on a software vendor contract. Every organizational leader or decision maker is aware of this pattern. A platform is selected after careful evaluation, sometimes with the help of global benchmarks and peer examples. A business case is built to show time-to-value improvement, lower operational costs, better compliance & innovation, onboarding of implementation partners, and then contracts are negotiated. Then the reality strikes, where integration takes longer than expected, legacy systems resist new pipelines, and governance processes do not align with the automation, amongst others.

The result of multiple QKS Group’s surveys, conducted across 27 countries and with 1573 decision makers present across multiple industry verticals, highlights the issue that has been consistently observed for a long time: “The adoption is strong in pockets, but weak in the core”, and “the value appears in isolated metrics but not in the overall business outcome.”

The instinctive narrative that follows is almost always the same: the vendor overpromised and underdelivered. This is a comfortable narrative as it externalizes the problem, but macro evidence from the same survey tells us something more uncomfortable: “the organizations that succeed with digital solutions are not simply those that bought better tools, they are those that prepared their IT infrastructure with future readiness to accommodate solutions that don’t require too much calibration.” To understand why, we need to walk through the full chain: the promises vendors make, why those promises often fail in practice, why that failure is justifiable from the vendor’s perspective, why enterprises must accept their share of responsibility, and what a new balanced model of shared accountability looks like.

Stats that will make everyone worry

Transformation & Delivery Failure Rates

  • Bain’s 2024 Transformation and Change Survey shows only 12% of business transformations fully achieve their business ambition, leaving 88% falling short.
  • McKinsey’s long-running work on transformations reaches a similar conclusion: around 70% of transformations fail to meet their objectives.
  • When you enhance the lens on larger IT programmes, an earlier McKinsey/Oxford study of 5400+ IT projects found that, on average, they run 45% over budget, 7% over time, and deliver 56% less value than forecast, while 17% go so badly that they threaten the company’s viability.

AI & Emerging Technology Value Gap

  • The pattern has been observed getting repeated in newer domains also: BCG’s 2024 global AI study reports that 74% of companies have yet to show tangible value from AI, despite significant spend, with only a minority operating as true AI “leaders”.
  • A 2025 MIT study on generative AI deployments goes further, estimating that roughly 95% of GenAI projects are failing to produce meaningful business outcomes, even as billions flow into tools and pilots.

Structural Readiness & Global Constraints

  • UNCTAD’s World Investment Report 2025 notes that the digital economy is growing 10-12% a year, faster than global GDP, yet less than one-third of the greenfield investment in digital sectors reaches developing countries, and in the global south, about 80% of digital projects go to just 10 economies. Core digital infrastructure and least-developed countries are largely bypassed.
  • QKS Group’s survey titled “Assessment of IT Evolution in the age of AI, 2025” conveyed “The user base present across the USA and Western Europe, specifically from IT, Healthcare, and BFSI verticals, has been reported to be only 50-60% satisfied with the performance of the “specialized solutions” that claimed to provide complete transformation of the existing functions.”
  • At a macro level, UNCTAD and WTO highlight that many firms, especially in developing markets, still face weak digital skills, fragile infrastructure and incomplete regulatory frameworks, which systematically limit their ability to translate technology investment into productivity and trade gains.

Taken together, these numbers are not a verdict on software quality alone; they highlight a capability and execution gap inside user organizations. Multiple global studies show that 60%-70% of digital and IT transformation efforts miss their objective, typically not due to software defects, but due to unclear ownership, weak change management, fragmented processes, skills gap, and an assumption that technology alone will fix structural problems. In other words, user organizations share equal responsibility: without clear ownership, skilled talent, process readiness, or a cultural willingness to change, even the best and established solutions fail to perform. Digital literacy, governance maturity, and execution discipline are now as essential as features and licensing.

The true transformation will occur when both sides elevate their responsibility: vendors in enablement and the user organisation in adoption excellence, to achieve value from the solution and avoid recurring disappointment.

What Vendors claim and why decision makers are rational in believing it

When an IT solution vendor enters the boardroom, they arrive with a compelling story that directly speaks to the pressure leaders face. They do not lead with glossy claims detached from reality; instead, they demonstrate:

  • Code Moving from commit to production within minutes
  • Infrastructure scaling dynamically with demand
  • Policy & compliance controls embedded directly into pipelines
  • End-to-end dashboards connecting engineering activity to business outcomes
  • Reference customers achieving faster releases and reduced failure rates  

- The OECD has documented that, before the global financial crisis of 2008, labor productivity at the technological frontier grew at around 4-5%, compared with roughly 1% among non-frontier firms, and that even in the slower post-crisis period, frontier firms retained an advantage.

- UNCTAD estimates that exports of digitally deliverable services grew to nearly $ 3.94 trillion in 2022, representing about 30% growth over pre-pandemic levels, even as the traditional sector struggles.

So when a vendor says, “We will move you into the category of high-performance organizations”, leaders are not being naïve. They are making a rational bet based on competitive pressure and observable market dynamics. The disconnect begins when the platform itself is presented as the primary driver of success. The problem is that the promise is almost always presented as if the platform itself is the primary driver of the success, when in reality, the platform is only the finishing layer on top of deep organizational readiness. That omission is where expectations begin to diverge from reality. 

Why Vendors Fail in Practice

When implementation begins, the platform no longer lives in a controlled demonstration; it lives inside the technology estate shaped by years or decades of incremental decisions. Critical business processes rely on systems written in languages very few people master, integrations between applications have grown into fragile webs of bespoke scripts and point-to-point connectors, and infrastructure has evolved organically, with environments that are similar enough to confuse developers but different enough to break automation. Into this world comes a platform built on assumptions of consistency, observability, repeatability, and explicit rules. It expects dependencies to be known, not discovered via failures, and governance controls to be explicit and testable, not implicit and embodied in committees.

Under those conditions:

  • Even a simple automated pipeline can break for reasons no one anticipates.
  • Deployments that worked in demonstrations fail when confronted with a subtle difference between legacy environments.
  • Compliance modules that intend to codify policy are sidelined when risk teams insist on retaining manual checkpoints.
  • Monitoring and tracing tools reveal issues that have existed for years but were previously hidden or tolerated; now they appear as a constant stream of alerts with no plan or capacity to resolve them.

This is exactly where disappointment sets in. The vendor promised a modern, streamlined, automated delivery engine, but in reality, what user experience is a complex, fragile overlay sitting uncomfortably on top of an unmodernized core. The user organization concludes that the vendor failed to deliver and promised transformation, but in reality, the platform exposes the path to transformation, conveying that it cannot perform in the present environment of the organization.

Why Vendor Failure is Justifiable

Vendors operate under structural constraints that limit their ability to guarantee outcomes:

  • Sales Strategy centered around a competitive approach with intense pressure to show value
  • Compelling demand for ROI projections within budget cycles by buyers
  • Vendors cannot compel refactoring of legacy systems
  • Vendors cannot restructure teams or governance models
  • Vendors cannot mandate compliance behaviour changes

The only thing vendors can do is recommend, guide, and advise, but the final decision remains in the hands of customers. Institutions like the OECD and the World Bank, when examining why digital technology adoption does not translate into broad productivity gains, repeatedly highlight that the bottleneck is not the availability of technology but the capability and willingness of firms to reorganize themselves.

In many cases, what QKS Groups Survey, 2025 has conveyed is that “what looks like vendor underperformance is actually vendor failing in the face of an environment that refuses to transform”. Under these circumstances, vendor failure is less a breach of promise than a predictable outcome of misaligned responsibilities.

Why User Organisations Cannot Escape Responsibility   

Organizations often believe purchasing modern platforms equates to becoming a modern organization. This illusion allows leaders to assume that changes can be bought externally rather than constructed internally. This is not simply a misunderstanding of technology; it is a misunderstanding of themselves. Existing power structure, governance habits, approval rituals, and risk behaviour remain intact, while expectations of radically different outcomes persist.

Over time, organizations build structures optimized not for risk but for insulation. Individuals gain status from controlling bottlenecks, delaying decisions, and preserving manual authority. In this context, modern platforms are not perceived as neutral tools but as threats to relevance and safety.

This resistence manifests in predictable patterns:

  • Exceptions granted indefinitely for “critical systems” never migrated
  • “One-extra sign-off” added to automated workflows
  • Compliance reverting to manual reviews after initial friction
  • Architects protecting monoliths that preserve individual centrality

None of this is irrational at an individual level. But collectively, it ensures transformation stagnates while vendors become convenient scapegoats.

The ”why” is stark: it is easier for an organization to change its tools than to change its existing working flow. Admitting that the primary obstacle is internal would mean accepting that some of the very people and structures that made past success possible are now the main barrier to future survival. But as long as the user organization avoid confronting this internal responsibility, they will reproduce the same result, sophisticated capability sitting on top of an operating model that refuses to let it work.

Where Users need to focus Instead of Just Blaming Vendors

If user organizations genuinely want a different outcome, they have to move their attention from the question “which platform is the best?” and towards a more uncomfortable question: “What is it about the way we built that makes any platform struggle here?” This is not a semantic but a strategic shift, which changes the locus of control from the external vendor market to the internal design of the organization.

Decision Rights and Bottlenecks

  • Excessive approval layers slow delivery
  • Authority disconnected from those closest to the work
  • Platforms are ready long before their full-scale use is allowed

Failure Culture

  • Punitive accountability drives risk avoidance
  • Continuous delivery requires psychological safety and learning loops
  • Teams must be designed to fail safely, not avoid failure entirely

Economic Transparency

  • Few Organizations measure the cost of delay meaningfully
  • Invisible waiting costs normalize inefficiency
  • Without financial visibility, platforms are treated as optional accelerators

Adoption Theatre vs. Adoption Reality

  • Tools Deployed, Dashboards built, training completed, but behaviours unchanged
  • “Cloud Native” organizations still rely on spreadsheets and email approvals
  • Real value appears only when behaviours align with platform intent

QKS Group’s several surveys conducted in 2025 frequently surface this pattern: the same organization that proudly declares itself “cloud native” or “DevOps driven” also runs critical approval workflows through informal chats, emails, and spreadsheets. In that gap between narrative and reality, transformation value evaporates.    

User organizations need to focus, with discipline, on closing this gap by aligning behaviour with capability. That means asking for every aspect of the platform: are we using this in the way it was intended to unlock value, or have we bent it just enough to preserve our old habits behind a modern interface? Until this question is answered honestly and acted upon, blaming vendors is a distraction from the more important work.

What is the Ultimate Balance between vendors and Users to get 100% value?

The ultimate balance is not a fifty-fifty split of blame; it is a redefinition of roles. Vendors cannot be responsible for what they do not control, and the user organization cannot be absolved of the changes that only they can make. In a mature model, both sides accept that transformation is not something one party does to the other, but something they must build together on top of clearly understood responsibilities.

 

The shared responsibility emerges in the middle. When both parties anchor to these operational signals, the conversation shifts from “Did you deliver what you sold?” to “Did we execute the necessary changes required to get the best out of the implemented solution?” In this model, getting 100% out of the solution is not a matter of uncovering hidden features or better tuning configurations. It is the result of the vendor fully delivering capability and the user fully embracing the organizational cost of turning that capability into the new default. Anything less from either side, and the gap between policy and reality reopens.

Advisory for staying ahead in the Tech and Competition Landscape:

Organizations must prioritize foundational questions before implementation begins. Questions such as:

  • Are our processes aligned or structurally conflicting?
  • Is governance mature enough to support automation?
  • Are ownership and accountability clearly defined?
  • Is our architecture coherent, or a legacy patchwork?

Once these priority assessments are understood, the actual enabler becomes unmistakably clear:

  • Change Management cannot remain a ceremonial afterthought, as its importance is that of the structural mechanism through which new behaviours, governance models, and decision pathways are embedded into the fabric of everyday work. Without this, organizations inevitably revert to the comfort of legacy routines, rendering the solution little more than an expensive interface.
  • The same rigour applies to data migration & hygiene; modern systems depend on consistency, lineage clarity, and quality, and yet organizations routinely transport legacy data chaos into environments that were engineered for precision.
  • Beyond these two well-known failure points lies an equally critical trio that organizations ignore at their peril: the absence of a coherent operating model with clearly articulated ownership, the proliferation of divergent workflows that undermine standardization, and architectural landscapes so burdened by technical debt that new capabilities cannot take root.

These factors collectively define whether a solution becomes a catalyst for transformation or another layer of complexity.

This is where QKS Advisory becomes indispensable. Our research-driven advisory practice is built on the principle that transformation succeeds only when organizational readiness aligns with vendor capability. Through our SPARK Matrix evaluation, AI Maturity Matrix, TrendsNXT analysis, QKS VOC Resonance findings, and our deeply structured maturity frameworks, QKS Advisory provides vendors and organizations with the strategic intelligence needed to make informed, high-impact decisions. Our research illuminates the readiness factors, capability differentiators, user expectations, and market dynamics that shape whether technology investment ultimately succeeds. In a market where assumptions often overshadow analysis, QKS Advisory offers decision-grade quality, empowering organizations to align their priorities with measurable insights and enabling vendors to position themselves with precision. Through robust, independent research, QKS Advisory ensures that every technology decision is anchored in intelligence, not intuition, and supports organizations in confidently pursuing the full potential of their digital investment.   

Conclusion: Transformation will fail as long as organizations expect Technology to transform them   

The recurring pattern in digital transformation is not mysterious once the full chain of responsibility is examined. Vendors demonstrate what is possible under certain conditions and sell platforms that genuinely embody that possibility. User organizations, driven by competitive pressure and often by internal fatigue with stagnation, buy those platforms in the hope that they will provide a faster route to the future than the difficult work of reshaping themselves. The instinctive response is to declare that the vendor overpromised. It is a convenient story that protects internal structures and avoids confrontations with the real source of friction. But as QKS Group’s research and the broader body of evidence show, this narrative breaks down under scrutiny. The organizations that consistently realize value from their solutions are not those that found the perfect vendor; they are those that changed themselves to become the kind of environment in which modern platforms can function as intended.

The new mantra for successful digital transformation is: technology does not transform organizations; organizations transform themselves using technology as leverage. Vendors who ignore this will continue to sell into environments that cannot support their promises. User organizations that ignore this will keep buying platforms that reveal their shortcomings faster than they are prepared to address them. Until that agreement becomes the norm, the pattern will continue: large investments, partial adoption, disappointing outcomes, and comfortable stories about vendor failures. The moment organizations accept that they share, and in many cases own, the deeper reasons behind those disappointments is the moment transformation finally has a chance to become something more than a recurring item on the board agenda.

Disclaimer:

This blog is based on independent research and publicly available information. The insights presented reflect the views of QKS Group and are for informational purposes only. While we strive for accuracy, we do not guarantee completeness or absolute correctness. Vendors are welcome to provide clarifications or updates. If any vendor listed in this analysis wishes to provide additional context or clarification, we welcome a briefing call and will consider incorporating relevant updates. This analysis is not intended to disparage any vendor but to provide an informed, balanced perspective. We encourage open and constructive dialogue to foster transparency and a deeper understanding of the industry.

Author: Nikhilesh Naik, Associate Director at QKS Group